Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Architecture & History: My Big Fat Greek Architecture

The earliest structures built by man were simple shelters designed primarily to keep the elements out.  The builders were hunter-gatherers.  The structures were temporary and transient.  They were not, however, what we would consider "architecture".  As man moved to higher degrees of civilization and the division of labor came about, he began to think of built structures as more than simple shelters.  These structures began to reflect elements of art - a required condition of "architecture".  But when did this transformation take place?  I am reminded of a scene in the movie My Big Fat Greek Wedding in which the father of the bride is able to trace any word back to the the greek root.  In much the same way, I would contend that all "architecture" (at least in the West) can connect back to Greek roots.

The Classical Greek period lasted from the 5th to the 4th centuries BC.  Classical Greek buildings such as the Parthenon in Athens, completed in 438 BC, first inspired the builders of the Roman Empire. The Romans adopted and adapted the style.  Over the centuries the style has periodically fallen out of favor but has always resurrected in a slightly modified form, as a revival style.  Architecture can be connected to these Greek buildings without being stylistically similar.  The forms, massing, scale, and rhythm derived from these  are tools used by the creative architect, whether or not the architect is practicing in the "classical style".

The Parthenon - Athens, Greece
A fine example of this may be found in another Athens - Athens, Alabama.  Paul Rudolph, one of the most prominent architects of his day, designed a home for Mr. and Mrs. John W. Wallace.  The house was featured in many journals, including the Life magazine January 1964 edition.  Following are Rudolph's own remarks regarding the house:

"Years ago I designed a house in Alabama based on Greek revival architecture of the South. I was brought up in that area, I knew it well, and my first memories of architecture were the Greek Revival buildings of the area and the sharecroppers' cottages, both of which intrigued me no end. Both seemed to have a complete validity - in other words, vernacular and so-called high architecture. This house in Alabama has double-story-high porches on four sides, over-scaled columns not based on structural need but on character - yet it's a modern house. It doesn't ever deal with Greek columns, capitals and bases, cornices, nor the use of symbols, but the image of the south is very clear. The design comes from the climate, the environment, how people live, what was suitable. It gets very hot in summer; therefore, the enclosure is put in man-made shade, which lowers the energy consumption of the air-conditioning system. It has many symmetrical parts, but the circulation and spatial organization is asymmetrical. If you know the location of this house it is clear that it really comes from the Greek Revival architecture of the South, but it certainly doesn't have any Greek Revival symbols, although its image is similar because it tries to solve some of the same problems."
Davern, Jeanne M. "A Conversation with Paul Rudolph." Architectural Record 170 (March 1982): 90-97.

Wallace Residence Exterior Facade

Wallace Residence "back porch"
I contend that much can be learned from the architecture of the past. It can inspire and inform, as classical architecture inspired and informed Paul Rudolph in his design of the Wallace Residence.  I do however question the practice of some to literally duplicate large portions of prior works. Neither the copied work nor the derived work benefit.  If architecture (or any other form of art) is not of it's time, then it becomes stagnant.

Next time we'll see how the direction of architecture shifted radically around the turn of the 20th century as we explore how architecture connects to technology in ..... A Machine for Living.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Architecture & Nature: In the Beginning

In the previous posts we established that there are a myriad of architecture connections. There is one connection, however, that is more significant than all the others.....the connection of architecture to nature.  To understand this connection, one must first understand man's connection with nature. This connection goes back, way back, back to the beginning.
Garden of Eden

"In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth." So begins the Genesis story of creation. Continued, God separates the land from the water and then creates plant and animal life. Man and woman are created and given dominion over the earth. They are placed in the Garden of Eden and commanded to tend it.

This connection of man to nature is foundational to the Christian faith.  It is, however, not unique to Christianity.  The connection, in one form or another, is found in all major world religions, and even in Evolution. Man's connection to nature, all would agree, is in his DNA.


As a means of survival, man has always sought ways to protect himself from the elements.  Early hunter-gatherers constructed transient dwellings, grass huts really, partially dug into the earth.  For thousands of years man continued to construct forms of shelter from whatever nature provided around him.  Eskimos constructed igloos from ice, the Souix erected tepees composed of saplings and animal skins, and the Pueblo Indians carved their shelter into the sides of the canyons.  This connection with nature continued even as man moved into sedentary agricultural societies.  The connection changed form but remained none the less.

Cliff Dwelling

Due to advances in technology and transportation, modern man has sometimes created modern architecture which seems to have little in common with the nature surrounding him. However, this is certainly not always the case, as illustrated by Faye Jones' Thorncrown Chapel in Eureka Springs, Arkansas. As one follows the path from the parking lot, the chapel slowly reveals itself, growing from the forest floor, stretching for the sky, and branching out, like the surrounding trees. It has much in common with the nature of which it is a part.  The stone floors, transparent walls, and thin wooden frame are derived from the land and artfully arranged so as to mimic the nature from which they were extracted. Experiencing nature from within its confines takes man full circle, in appreciation of the creator of the chapel, but even more, in awe of the Creator of Nature.

Approach to Thorncrown Chapel

Interior of Thorncrown Chapel
In this post we've spent some time talking about shelter, followed by an analysis of a work of architecture.  In the next post, we'll investigate the difference between shelter and architecture when we look at the connection between Architecture and Form in ... My Big Fat Greek Architecture.